I've owned two pairs of these boots. One pair that I took care of and one pair that I neglected. The neglected pair went through six months of a hard surveying job going through swamps, forrests, farms, and dozens of homes. The boots held up. They took many ricochet machete swings into the toe, leaving a white gash that showed the composite toe underneath. I ditched them because a huge tear started on the inside left side of the left boot. This is because they were never oiled. The second pair have been very well cared for. I oil them at least twice a month in the summer and three times in the winter. These ones have slogged through New England snow and many many rough situations. The leather has been mildly scuffed from rubbing things but oiling the leather fixes this quickly. The boots are wicked comfortable and I wouldn't want anytihng else. A couple loose threads can be found around the boot, but I haven't had any complications or tears. It's been a year of almost everyday use and the only thing I replaced was the stock insert. I totally recommend doing this too, the boot will fit better and feel significantly better. Due to my loyal oiling, the boots look just like the day I bought them and are very waterproof. Buy these boots. They're unbeatable.

I got these boots Father's Day 2022. I've worn them 3 or 4hrs. a month. There is no tread wear yet the leather upper has separated from the plastic heel. It was good while it lasted.

I purchased these for work with the Forest Service. I am very pleased. The logger sole is great for outdoors and off-pavement. Sometimes logger soles can make boots uncomfortable for work on pavement, but these still feel great. I haven't had them long enough to give a fair review on durability, but they look great, feel great and appear to be excellent quality. Would recommend.

Great buy, very comfortable, feels like I'm wearing a top of the line boot for nearly 3/4 of the price, would definitely recommend

Good comfortable boot didten hurt my during the break in period ant had them long enough to see how they hold up

love these boot this is my 3rd pair. My only issue this time is that they went on sale a week after I bought them...

Terrible boots they're hard on your feet there's no room in them there's no flex in the soles I don't think I'll ever buy another pair after this pair I bought most TERRIBLE BOOTS EVER!!!!!!!!!!

Fit small, be sure to get wide because they are super narrow. Take awhile for your feet to break in.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Great boots so far. Much more comfortable than other brands I have owned.

I've used irishsters and Carolinas boots this boots lasted for 3 yrs in my line of work and different types of dirt and I'm very impressed with them and will keep buying more of th3m

I have only had them a week and so far they are great boots. The double rivets holding on the speed lacing hooks is a nice touch. I've tried other logger style boots where the fit was good in the store but slowly got worse and we returned. These boots felt good in the store and after a week of solid wear still feel good. I think they are keepers.

Good looking boot , need to break them in , warm , dry . Durable?????

Haven't worn them due to snow as they are very slippery. They are tight fitting compared to other brand logger style. I plan on breaking them in before I work in them. They look well made and stylish I believe they have potential. Should of got a half size bigger but they will work. Nothing negative about them other than they are very slippery in the winter.

I do a lot of industrial sandblasting in paper-mills and trash incinerators first time buying the boots a year ago instead of the usual pair of Chippewa boots with all the ash and lime and chemicals I encounter everyday they have out lasted any pair of Chippewa boots and definitely a better price and comfort I work in all elements of weather couldn’t ask for a better boot...

One of the most comfortable pair of boots I have

Third pair and by far the longest lasting boots I’ve ever had. Outlasts everyone else I know that wear other brands . Amazing boots

So far so good. Took a few days to break in. Very comfortable. Time will tell on how they hold up.

So far they are great. I have no complaints. Comfortable when climbing or on the ground.

Very sturdy and comfortable. You can see and feel the great quality!

Bought these boots about a month ago. Let me just say I love carhartt and have everything else they make but have worn red wing loggers for quite some time. I thought I would give these a try to support a great company and they are a little cheaper. Honestly my feet froze today in 15 degree weather with two pairs of think socks. They also let moisture through, I stepped into a mud puddle about 3 inches deep and I could feel moisture right at the stitching. The one good thing I will say is they have very good traction in mud and snow. Disappointing

I've worn these boots for a little over two years I ware them all day every day from ridding my motorcycle to work they have held together vary well the sole is flat from so much walking just today they started to leak on the side vary sad but they have done very well would buy again

Have worn them regularly for a a good year. I am not easy on my boots. They did a good job and have been very comfortable however; they have started coming apart prematurely. I normally only wear Chippewa boots, I figured I would try the carhartt. Comparing the two carhartt has disappointed me by not going the distance. It may be a fluke however I won't be taking the chance again.

Just got them, but it is the 3rd pair I have owned. Sure they will as good as the last 2 pairs, I am a Forester and I use them daily in the woods. Slim! the Forester

Best boot i have had. I just looked back at my purchase it was 10/10/18. It is now 9/13/20. So almost 2 years. I came here to buy a new pair for winter because they are no longer water prof. But for 2 years they have held up great. I have literally never in my life had a pair that lasted more then a year and a half. I remember when i first got them. No break in time. They were comfortable right out of the box. I do use dr shools custom fit insoles. I am a mechanic about 50 percent of the year. A truck driver about 30 percent, and farmer about 20 percent of the year. I cut my own firewood. These boots have been through everything. No ripped stitches, no tears. Still perfectly wearable, i am still wearing them everyday, but worried about winter getting here soon so its time to replace them. The composite toe does rub a little bit on one toe, but thats the way my feet are, every steel toe or composite toe boot i have ever had does it. But these rub the least of any.

Very sturdy boot. Took a while to break in before they were comfortable. Thought I had a winner until the first rainy day and had to work with damp socks all day long. Even worse, now that the weather has finally started to warm up my feet are sweating like crazy and it's not even close to hot yet! Maybe the membrane they're so proud about in the description got sewn in backwards?

This is my first time buying Carhartt boots and I am very happy with them.they are comfortable and lightweight.

No black that's all other than that the best boots ever

Great work boot for the winter Need a pair just like those not insulated

I have had 2 pair of these boots and will get another pair. Great boot and great durability!!

Took longer than I thought to break in an the nub on the inside for the laces to hook around rubbed right on my ankle an was uncomfortable. Just left them loose on the bottom two hooks an problem was solved.