Hard to rate a shoe, I feel, because feet and humans are so different. The quality of construction seemed fine at the price, I like that it was made in USA, so as far as that goes 5 star and prompt delivery and all that. I had to return (didn't like having to pay return shipping but really I guess that's fair) for the following reasons: In most shoes a 12EE works for me, this was just a bit too short and narrow. Maybe the rounded toe would have been better? Pretty steep drop-off once your foot gets over the heel too, for me it was uncomfortable and it would have surely made this a dress boot because walking/standing would not be an option. Maybe it would have molded to my foot.

The boots are great I have had these before and they last feel and look great. I am a retail guy and am on my feet all day never sit down and when I get home my feet never hurt at all! Great boots!

boots arrived quickly ,fit perfectly and i am very happy with them.

Great boot. Fit is excellent, true to standard size, Looks very nice. Living in Minnesota, I like to wear a boot that covers my ankles, but higher cowboy boots aren't appropriate in the office. These boots set the bar. Not your ho hum footwear.

The variety of sizes and width and the softness of the boots make them a nice choice.

Boots are well made, comfortable and attractive. It would be great if these boots were made in other colors as wel like medium brown or chestnut

The boot looks great and even better made in us. Not so great did not have a removable insole and existing built in was not as comfortable. Had to install an insole. Putting them on it’s a bit challenging it would have been great to have a loop to pull them on to your foot.

All the folks at Boot Barn were very helpful in me getting these boots.Thank you.

Good looking and comfortable boot. Love the extra cushioning.

Excellent quality, perfect fit at a reasonable price and MADE IN THE USA!